Friday, March 9, 2007

Sacred/Secular and Other False Dichotomies

Maybe you've seen this video or the others in the series. These parodies of the Mac/PC commercials pit a stereotypical conservative Evangelical-ish Christian in suit and tie against a jeans/t-shirt/hoodie clad "Christ-follower". Obviously one is cool and one isn't. Now, I am sensitive to insulting people who aren't "cool" - and the video series does bug me a bit in that regard. However, the point I want to cull from this video is important - at least in my opinion.



Here's the deal. I think it is our tendency to create false dichotomies. We make two piles when there could be many. We limit ourselves to two choices, when there may be...oh...at least three.

But what troubles me is when we pull this tendency into the arena of faith and religion - specifically, the sacred/secular dichotomy. Who draws the lines? Do we have to draw lines? I have a friend, Jewish by birth and culture, who had a spiritual awakening sitting in his car listening to U2 in his high school's parking lot. My husband found God on a cliff overlooking the Pacific. My life as a Christ-follower has been shaped by Pulp Fiction and Crash - two movies that might not pass muster in many a "sacred throng".

I am sure that MY life has been most influenced by the Bible and the discourse I've been a part of in church communities and relationships with other Christians. But what I don't buy into this idea that God is restricted to "sacred" media. I can't say "everything is sacred" - I have a hard time finding anything uplifting in pornography for example. But I'm leaning hard toward beauty - whether art, music, or my sons large yet perfectly proportioned four year old hands - as an echo of divine wonderment. Wouldn't our lives be richer if we looked for Truth and Love in every nook and cranny of existence?

THIS IS EXACTLY THE KIND OF THING I'M TALKING ABOUT! http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/T/TV_AMERICAN_IDOL_SLIGH?SITE=IAIOP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT

4 comments:

Lon Marshall said...

You people have a cool beginning here. You need a way to contact you and Ray the Very Hairy needs a picture on his bio. Keep up the good work.

Heather Weber said...

Nancy, just curious: what was the intended audience for this "commercial." What was its original purpose?

I totally get where you're coming from in bashing the fake dichotomies. I love that you guys are writing/thinking like this and doing it "out loud". Makes me want to change the world.

Ray Weikal said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
nancy said...

Thanks HW - glad that you're engaging. We'd love to hear your thoughts too.

I don't know the original context. I think it comes from a Chicagoland church called Community Christian Church.